Effective workforce management is a cornerstone of successful healthcare operations. Given the dynamic nature of patient needs and the complexities of the labor market, healthcare facilities must carefully consider how they structure their workforce. Understanding the pros and cons different staffing models healthcare organizations can implement is vital for making strategic decisions that balance cost, flexibility, and quality of care. Conducting a thorough healthcare staffing models comparison is essential to identify the optimal approach for a facility’s unique needs. Exploring the various types of healthcare staffing models advantages disadvantages they offer allows leaders to build a resilient and efficient workforce strategy.
Healthcare staffing models are essentially the frameworks organizations use to employ, schedule, and manage their clinical and support staff. These models range from relying primarily on full-time permanent employees to utilizing a variety of external resources. There is no one-size-fits-all solution; the ideal model or blend of models depends heavily on a facility’s size, location, patient population, and operational goals. This article provides a healthcare staffing models comparison, detailing the types of healthcare staffing models advantages disadvantages associated with internal and external approaches, and discusses how facilities can find the right balance in their healthcare staffing strategies.
Table of Contents
Disclaimer Note
This blog post offers a general overview of common healthcare staffing models and their typical pros and cons. The actual outcomes, costs, and challenges experienced with each model can vary significantly based on the specific healthcare facility’s management practices, local labor market conditions, the quality of internal float pool or per diem staff, and the effectiveness of external staffing partners. This content is intended for general informational purposes and strategic consideration, not as definitive financial or operational advice.
What Are Healthcare Staffing Models?
Healthcare staffing models are the frameworks or structures that healthcare organizations use to organize, schedule, and manage their clinical and non-clinical workforce. They define how staff are employed, allocated, and deployed to meet patient care needs and operational demands. These models are a critical component of overall healthcare workforce models and strategic workforce planning.
Healthcare Staffing Models Comparison: Internal Models
Internal staffing models rely on employees directly hired and managed by the healthcare facility. Here’s a look at the types of healthcare staffing models advantages disadvantages of common internal approaches.
Permanent/Full-time Staffing
This traditional model involves hiring staff as full-time or part-time employees with set schedules and benefits.
Pros (Advantages)
- Stability and Continuity: Provides a consistent team, fostering strong relationships and continuity of care.
- Institutional Knowledge: Permanent staff develop deep familiarity with the facility’s protocols, systems, and culture.
- Cultural Fit: Easier integration into the organization’s culture.
- Potential for Lower Long-Term Cost: While fixed costs are higher, the per-hour cost over time can be lower than temporary staff.
- Employee Loyalty and Engagement: Can foster greater loyalty and engagement among staff.
Cons (Disadvantages)
- Limited Flexibility: Difficult to rapidly adjust staffing levels in response to unexpected fluctuations in patient census.
- Risk of Understaffing/Overstaffing: Can lead to burnout during high census periods or inefficient use of resources during low census.
- Higher Fixed Costs: Salaries and benefits represent significant ongoing expenses.
- May Contribute to Burnout: Staff may be stretched thin if supplemental support isn’t available during peak times.
Internal Float Pool
An internal float pool consists of employees hired directly by the facility but assigned to work across various units or departments as needed.
Pros (Advantages)
- Internal Flexibility: Provides flexibility to cover staffing gaps across multiple units within the facility.
- Facility Familiarity: Float pool staff are familiar with the facility’s layout, systems, and general protocols.
- Potential Cost Savings: Can be less expensive than relying solely on external agency staff for flexible needs.
Cons (Disadvantages)
- Maintaining Competency: Float staff must maintain competency across a range of clinical areas, which can be challenging.
- Feeling Disconnected: Float staff may feel less connected to a specific team or unit, potentially impacting morale and engagement.
- Scheduling Complexity: Managing the scheduling and assignments for a float pool requires dedicated resources and sophisticated systems.
- Requires Dedicated Management: An effective float pool needs strong leadership and administrative support.
Internal PRN/Per Diem Staffing
PRN (as needed) or Per Diem staff are internal employees who work on an irregular basis, often without benefits, to fill urgent or short-term needs.
Pros (Advantages)
- High Flexibility: Excellent for filling last-minute needs and adapting to unpredictable spikes in demand.
- Often Facility-Familiar: Can be beneficial if the per diem staff have previously worked at the facility.
- Can Be Cost-Effective: May be cost-effective for filling specific shifts without the overhead of benefits.
Cons (Disadvantages)
- Less Commitment: PRN staff may have less organizational loyalty compared to permanent staff.
- Scheduling Challenges: Ensuring adequate and consistent coverage can be difficult due to the unpredictable nature of PRN availability.
- May Require Incentives: May need to offer higher pay rates or incentives for undesirable shifts.
Healthcare Staffing Models Comparison: External Models
External staffing models involve partnering with outside organizations to provide staff. Understanding internal staffing vs external staffing healthcare options is key. These are the types of healthcare staffing models advantages disadvantages of external approaches.
Staffing Agency (Temporary/Contract)
Healthcare staffing agencies provide temporary or contract healthcare professionals to facilities to cover absences, manage peak workloads, or fill vacancies.
Pros (Advantages)
- Maximum Flexibility and Responsiveness: Can rapidly deploy staff to meet immediate or unexpected needs.
- Access to Specialized Skills: Agencies often have access to professionals with niche skills or certifications that may not be readily available internally.
- Reduces Internal HR Burden: Recruitment, vetting, and credentialing responsibilities typically fall on the agency.
- Helps Manage Staffing Shortages: Provides a crucial resource during widespread labor shortages.
Cons (Disadvantages)
- Higher Hourly Rates: Generally more expensive on an hourly basis compared to permanent or internal float staff.
- Less Institutional Knowledge: Temporary staff may be less familiar with facility-specific protocols and culture.
- Integration Challenges: May take time for temporary staff to integrate with the permanent team.
- Quality Can Vary: The quality of professionals can differ depending on the agency’s vetting and credentialing processes.
Managed Service Provider (MSP)
An MSP is a third-party company that manages a healthcare facility’s entire external staffing process, working with multiple staffing agencies.
Pros (Advantages)
- Centralized Management: Streamlines the process of working with multiple agencies through a single point of contact.
- Streamlined Processes: Improves efficiency in areas like order fulfillment, billing, and reporting.
- Potential for Cost Control and Compliance: Can help negotiate rates and ensure compliance across all agency staff.
Cons (Disadvantages)
- Reduced Direct Relationship: Facilities may have less direct interaction with the individual staffing agencies providing staff.
- Implementation Complexity: Setting up an MSP program can be complex.
- Potential for Some Loss of Control: The MSP framework defines how staffing needs are met, potentially reducing some direct control for the facility.
Recruitment Process Outsourcing (RPO) / Permanent Placement Agency
RPO providers or permanent placement agencies specialize in finding and recruiting candidates for permanent, direct-hire positions within a healthcare facility.
Pros (Advantages)
- Specialized Permanent Recruitment Expertise: Highly skilled in identifying, attracting, and vetting candidates for permanent roles.
- Wider Candidate Reach: Access to a broad network of potential candidates, including passive job seekers.
- Saves Internal HR Time: Handles the intensive process of permanent recruitment, freeing up internal resources.
- Effective for Hard-to-Fill Roles: Particularly valuable for leadership positions or highly specialized roles.
Cons (Disadvantages)
- Fees Can Be High: Placement fees are typically a percentage of the hired candidate’s salary.
- Focus on Permanent Hires: Not designed to address temporary or flexible staffing needs.
Finding the Right Blend: Healthcare Staffing Strategies
For most healthcare facilities, the most effective approach is not to rely on a single model but to develop integrated healthcare staffing strategies that leverage a blend of internal and external resources. This requires a careful healthcare staffing models comparison based on specific needs. The goal is to create robust healthcare workforce models that offer both stability and flexibility.
A blended approach might involve a strong core of permanent staff, supplemented by an internal float pool for routine internal coverage, internal per diem staff for short-notice needs, and external staffing agencies for peak demand, specialized roles, or extended vacancies. Implementing strategic workforce planning is essential to determine the optimal mix.
Factors Influencing the Choice of Healthcare Staffing Models
Several factors should influence a healthcare facility’s decision when evaluating the types of healthcare staffing models advantages disadvantages they present.
Facility Size and Type
A large hospital system may have the resources to support a robust internal float pool, while a smaller clinic might rely more heavily on a blend of permanent and external per diem or agency staff.
Budget and Financial Constraints
The cost per hour varies significantly between models. Facilities must consider their budget when determining the right mix.
Patient Census Predictability
Facilities with highly unpredictable patient volumes may require greater reliance on flexible models like internal per diem or agency staffing.
Need for Specialized Skills
If a facility frequently needs professionals with rare or highly specialized skills, external agencies or RPO providers with access to those talent pools may be essential.
Internal HR Capacity
Facilities with limited internal HR resources may benefit from external partners who handle recruitment, vetting, and credentialing.
Organizational Culture and Goals
The desired organizational culture and long-term strategic goals should also inform staffing model choices, considering the impact on staff morale, continuity of care, and integration.
Hathaway Healthcare Staffing: Your External Staffing Partner
At Hathaway Healthcare Staffing, we understand the complexities healthcare facilities face in navigating the pros and cons different staffing models healthcare offers. We recognize that effectively managing a healthcare workforce requires a strategic blend of internal stability and external flexibility.
Hathaway specializes in providing high-quality external staffing solutions, including temporary, contract, per-diem, and permanent placements. We are a trusted partner that complements your internal staffing models by offering rapid access to vetted professionals to address staffing gaps, manage fluctuating census, and provide specialized skills. We understand the healthcare staffing agency pros cons and are committed to maximizing the advantages for our partners – delivering reliable, qualified talent to enhance your staffing flexibility healthcare wide and support your overall healthcare workforce models and healthcare staffing strategies. We help you achieve the balance needed to ensure optimal patient care.
Building a Resilient Healthcare Workforce
Choosing the right mix of healthcare staffing models is a critical strategic decision for healthcare facilities aiming for operational efficiency and quality patient care. Understanding the pros and cons different staffing models healthcare offers, and conducting a thorough healthcare staffing models comparison based on your facility’s unique needs, is essential.
By evaluating the types of healthcare staffing models advantages disadvantages each presents, including internal staffing vs external staffing healthcare options, facilities can implement effective healthcare staffing strategies. Leveraging a blended approach that combines the stability of permanent staff with the flexibility of internal float pools or per diem staff, and partnering with reliable external providers like Hathaway Healthcare Staffing for supplemental needs, helps build resilient healthcare workforce models capable of navigating the challenges of the modern healthcare landscape. Making informed choices about your staffing models is an investment in the future of your facility and the quality of care you provide.
Disclaimer Note: This blog post offers a general overview of common healthcare staffing models and their typical pros and cons. The actual outcomes, costs, and challenges experienced with each model can vary significantly based on the specific healthcare facility’s management practices, local labor market conditions, the quality of internal float pool or per diem staff, and the effectiveness of external staffing partners. This content is intended for general informational purposes and strategic consideration, not as definitive financial or operational advice.
